The GOP won on Thursday in Tennessee. They’ll lose the fight on gun safety | John L. Micek
Expelling two Black lawmakers for protecting children, Republicans ‘lost an entire generation of voters,’ Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta said
Rep. Justin Jones, left, and Justin Pearson, right, were expelled from the Tennessee House. On April 10, 2023, the Metro Nashville Council reappointed Jones to his seat until a special election can be held. (Photo: John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout)
In the annals of brazenly destructive attacks on democracy, Thursday’s vote by Tennessee’s Republican-controlled state House to expel two Democratic lawmakers who led a decorum-busting protest over the cold-blooded murders of children is right up there.
The hard reality that both of the expelled lawmakers were young Black men, while another lawmaker who avoided expulsion was a white woman, was impossible to avoid, adding an element of ugly racial politics to what already was a kangaroo court proceeding.
In case you missed it, state Reps. Justin Jones, of Nashville; Justin Pearson, of Memphis, and Gloria Johnson, of Knoxville, disrupted the House’s proceedings last week for an utterly unthinkable 15 seconds, prompting a 45-minute delay in the people’s business, as they called for action in the wake of a mass shooting at a Christian school in Nashville last month that left three children and three adults dead.
Jones and Pearson, both of whom are Black, were booted from the chamber. Johnson, who is white, narrowly avoided expulsion.
The vote, which came days after Wisconsin voters resoundingly elected a progressive to that state’s highest court, securing the first liberal majority in 15 years, and the election of a solidly progressive candidate as Chicago’s next mayor, put the cap on a week that left Republicans looking even more dramatically out of step with the mood of the country.
Tuesday’s arraignment in a Manhattan courtroom of former President Donald Trump, whom Republicans steadfastly refuse to abandon, no matter how damaging he is to the party’s national fortunes, certainly didn’t help either.
But this historic act of partisan overreaction and retaliation is par for the course for a Republican Party that, while enjoying majorities in state legislatures and governor’s mansions, has nonetheless not won the presidential popular vote in nearly 20 years, and continues to insist on polarizing policies that cater to an ever-shrinking base.
The irony is that Tennessee Republicans could have pursued any course of action, short of this political death sentence, if they wanted to punish Democrats for what amounted to an essential act of political theater.
Democrats noted that Republicans in the chamber had evaded censure even though they had been accused of more serious criminal offenses, the Guardian reported.
It also, in the end, was a missed opportunity for Republicans to stand with Democrats on an issue that impacts all of us: The ongoing, wholesale, and absolutely avoidable slaughter of our children.
And if you think such an act is a political impossibility, I’d urge you to consider the example of Pennsylvania in 2020, where Black Democratic lawmakers engineered a takeover of the House floor to call for the passage of police reform bills at the height of that summer of civil rights unrest.
In that instance, rather than punish the protesters, who most assuredly blew through the chamber’s decorum rules, then-GOP House Speaker Mike Turzai, of Allegheny County, backed the reform push and called for a special session on the issue.
That act of compromise ended up a win for both sides.
Republicans got to look reasonably sensible as they defended their majority during the 2020 presidential cycle. And it was a victory for Democrats, who could point to the still-potent power of organizing and protest as a force for social change during a period of seismic change in our national dialogue.
There is no denying that the force of public opinion is on the side of common sense gun violence reduction measures.
And the fear that takes hold in your throat when you send a loved one — teacher, student, aide, cafeteria worker, custodian, or administrator — off to school on the morning after yet another mass shooting, hoping they will come home to you alive, respects no partisan boundary.
So there was a chance here for Republicans to do something — anything — however modest to stem the bloodshed. The eyes of the world — and the eyes of the tens of thousands of Tennesseans who are now without representation — were on them.
But they blew it. Completely.
The overreach, of course, is familiar. Not content with toppling Roe v. Wade, GOP lawmakers and their allies are mounting brutal attacks on the remaining avenues to abortion access. Not content with control over local school boards, they look to ban books and to disappear transgender and LGBTQ+ kids from their own communities.
The victories, however, also have been Pyrrhic.
Voters in Kansas last year rejected a Republican-backed effort to strip abortion protections from the Sunflower State’s constitution. Attacks on abortion rights and voting rights helped Democrats erase what initially was expected to be a wave year for the GOP in last year’s midterm elections.
Taking to Twitter on Thursday, Pennsylvania state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta, a Philadelphia Democrat and former 2022 U.S. Senate candidate who is among the party’s rising stars, predicted that Republicans had “lost an entire generation of voters.
“We’ve witnessed, in all its naked ugliest, the sins of racism and authoritarianism on full display,” Kenyatta, who’s currently seeking the Democratic nomination for state auditor general, continued. “You can’t expel a movement. You can’t silence the cry for justice. You can’t put out the flame of liberty.”
If there is a sea change in our long overdue national reckoning on gun violence, historians may point to Thursday night in Nashville as the moment everything changed.
Pennsylvania Capital-Star is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Pennsylvania Capital-Star maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor John Micek for questions: [email protected]. Follow Pennsylvania Capital-Star on Facebook and Twitter.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.
John L. Micek